Dave Portnoy’s Nantucket dream home is a stunning waterfront estate located in the Monomoy neighborhood of Nantucket Island, Massachusetts. It is a record-breaking property purchase, bought for $42 million, which set the highest residential sale price in Massachusetts history. The estate spans 1.2 acres and includes two waterfront lots with a 5,200-square-foot primary residence, complemented by a two-bedroom guest house and a pool. The home offers spectacular sunset views over Nantucket Harbor and the historic downtown area of the island.
The property features a private beach as a backyard, a pool with a covered patio, and an outdoor TV, making it perfect for outdoor entertaining. The home is designed for both luxury and practicality, making it ideal for hosting significant events with its versatile spaces and breathtaking views. Dave Portnoy, founder of Barstool Sports, frequently shares images of the view and the bay, highlighting his affection for the estate, though he primarily resides in Miami for tax reasons. The purchase also included approximately $2 million worth of furnishings, enhancing the luxurious setting of the compound.
| Category | Information |
|---|---|
| Full Name | David Scott Portnoy |
| Date of Birth | March 22, 1977 |
| Age | 48 years (as of 2025) |
| Birthplace | Swampscott, Massachusetts, USA |
| Nationality | American |
| Profession | Businessman, podcast host, blogger, founder of Barstool Sports |
| Education | University of Michigan, degree in education, graduated 1999 |
| Height | 6 feet |
| Weight | 67 kg |
| Spouse | Renee Satterthwaite (married 2009, separated 2017) |
| Current Partner | Silvana Mojica (dated 2021 to 2023) |
| Net Worth | Estimated around $150 million (2025), some sources claim up to $470 million |
| Residences | Miami, FL home (approx. $17 million), Nantucket, MA island home (approx. $43 million), Montauk, NY house ($9.8 million), Saratoga Springs, NY house ($1.4 million) |
| Notable Personal Notes | Filed bankruptcy in 2004 due to gambling losses; involved in Barstool Fund supporting small businesses during COVID-19; separated but not formally divorced from Renee, with shared financial accounts |
This home stands out not only for its grandeur and location but also as a statement piece amongst other notable affluent residents in Nantucket, including billionaires and celebrities. Despite its grandeur, the publicly shared interior details are limited; however, it notably features a comfortable living space, a kitchen, and ample accommodations for guests.
Who is Dave Portnoy?
Dave Portnoy is an American businessman and social media personality, best known as the founder and owner of Barstool Sports, a popular sports and culture media company. He was born on 22 March 1977, in Massachusetts, and initially started Barstool Sports as a free sports newspaper in Boston before expanding it into a widely popular digital platform. Portnoy is also known for his outspoken persona, called “El Presidente,” and his “One Bite” pizza reviews. Beyond media, he is a notable public figure for his political commentary and strong support of Donald Trump. His business ventures include selling stakes in Barstool Sports and then repurchasing the company, with a net worth estimated at around $150 million. Portnoy has cultivated a large following on social media platforms and has been influential in online discussions about sports and culture.
Where Does Dave Portnoy Currently Live?
Dave Portnoy currently lists his primary residence in Miami, Florida. Although he owns a $42 million “dream house” in Nantucket, Massachusetts, which is the most expensive home sale in Massachusetts history, he does not live there full-time. He keeps Miami as his primary residence mainly for tax reasons, since Florida has no state income tax. In contrast, Massachusetts taxes personal income at 5%, allowing him to keep a larger portion of his income. Besides Miami and Nantucket, he also owns other properties, including one in Saratoga.
You may also read (inside eli mannings luxurious home a virtual tour).
Dave Portnoy’s Nantucket House Interior and Exterior
Dave Portnoy’s Nantucket house is a luxurious waterfront compound located in the Monomoy area, purchased for a record $42 million. The property spans 1.2 acres and includes a 5,200-square-foot main house with four bedrooms. The interior features a casual yet elegant design, highlighted by a double-height entry foyer with a sculptural staircase. The living room has a freestanding fireplace and sunburst-inspired chandeliers. The kitchen boasts a marble eat-in island, and the primary bedroom suite includes a private terrace with an outdoor shower and retractable glass doors that open to stunning views of Nantucket Harbor.
| Attribute | Details |
|---|---|
| House Location | Nantucket, Massachusetts (Monomoy area) and Miami, Florida |
| Nantucket Property | Waterfront compound on 1.2 acres featuring a main residence, guesthouse, and studio connected by underground tunnel |
| Miami Property | Bayfront home in Miami, Florida |
| House Size (Nantucket) | Main house plus guest house and studio; main house with 4 bedrooms |
| House Size (Miami) | 7,011 square feet, 9 bedrooms, 9 bathrooms |
| Architecture Design | Nantucket estate designed by Andrew Kotchen of Workshop/APD; Miami architecture details not specified |
| Architecture Style | Modern luxury waterfront design |
| Unique Features | Underground tunnel connecting structures (Nantucket); indoor/outdoor shower in primary suite |
| Purchase Price (Nantucket) | $42 million; set a residential record for Nantucket and Massachusetts |
| Additional Cost | Approximately $2 million spent on furnishings and extras at Nantucket property |
| Miami Property Purchase Info | Owned by Dave Portnoy, located on N Bayshore Dr, Miami, FL 33137 |
| Property History | Nantucket property acquired through two adjacent lots bought in 2016, demolished existing homes for redevelopment |
| Notable Architects | Andrew Kotchen (Nantucket) |
| Worth (estimated) | Dave Portnoy net worth approx. $120 million |
Outside, the estate offers a pool area and a private backyard beach. The property also includes a detached two-bedroom guest house and a studio, both connected to the main house through a unique underground tunnel allowing movement between structures without stepping outside. The design and architecture firm behind the home is Workshop/APD. The house was built around 2018 and furnished with an additional $2 million spent on luxury furniture and extras. These features combine to create a high-end modern waterfront living experience with a touch of privacy and elegance.
Dave Portnoy’s Nantucket House History Address and Wroth
Dave Portnoy owns a record-breaking Nantucket estate purchased for $42 million, setting the highest residential real estate sale in Massachusetts history. The property is located in the Monomoy district at 68 and 72 Monomoy Road, combining two waterfront lots spanning about 1.2 acres. The estate features a primary residence of approximately 5,200 square feet, a two-bedroom guest house, and a pool, all boasting 180-degree sunset views over Nantucket Harbor. The homes were designed by architect Andrew Kotchen of Workshop/APD, with landscaping by Miroslava Ahern, and built by Reid Builders in 2018-2019. The two houses are connected by an underground tunnel.
Dave Portnoy’s Nantucket House
You may also read (discover the legacy of dan quayles house today).
